Businesses could face additional costs from EU ruling - Palmers Solicitors

Businesses could face additional costs from EU ruling

by Lara Murray

The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has said that the time spent travelling to and from first and last appointments by workers who do not have a fixed place of work should be regarded as working time and that employees should be paid.

It comes after workers from the Spanish firm Tyco Integrated Security brought their company before a court in their home country arguing that they should be paid for their travel time to and from work.

The court heard that staff at the business were provided with a company vehicle and a work schedule and travelled to different customers’ premises every day. Their employer argued that for working time purposes, the time they spent going from their homes to their first job, and from their last job back to their homes, was not working time. The Spanish courts referred the issue to the CJEU and following a hearing, the Court has given a preliminary ruling.

They found that employees’ time spent travelling to the first job and to their homes after the last job was working time for the purposes of the working time rules, adding that the test should be whether, at a particular time, the employees were:

  • at the workplace
  • at the disposal of the employer
  • carrying out activities or duties of their job

With more time being brought into the scope of working time, there will be additional time that workers will be entitled to be paid for; further, there is also a risk that some workers might be in breach of the 48-hour limit on the working week. This is an issue that I have spoken about on the BBC Radio Essex Radio Dave Monk show and it is something that will affect mobile workers such as carers, technicians, and sales people.

If you would like more information about how you or your employees could be affected by this new ruling, or you have questions about any other employment law issue, please contact me at